Writing is a lot like parenting. You don’t want someone else making decisions on your behalf. And, most important, you want messages to be stated in your voice. For that reason, it’s easy to fear bringing in an editor. Who knows what they’ll do to your baby?
But effective editors don’t want to make your work their own. A great editor wants to help you make your work shine.
As a former schoolteacher, I see the similarities in guiding writers and guiding students. In a constructive learning environment, teachers collaborate with students. Students grow into writers when they’re actively involved in creating their meaning. Writers improve their writing through active collaboration with their editor.
This includes
- asking and answering questions
- choosing to accept or reject suggested changes
- considering other perspectives
An editor should be able to envision how the final product should look and lead you in the right direction. You and your editor will have different perspectives. The combination of diverse viewpoints will enhance your work. With an editor on your side, you’ll become a more proficient writer. Be open to the guidance of an editor.
Do you think that a writer’s relationship with an editor should be constructive?
There’s a term in education called scaffolding. It refers to a collaborative form of learning support given to students. Scaffolding can come in many forms. For example, a teacher may break down a larger concept into smaller parts and guide students to understanding by asking targeted questions that encourage thought. Just like teachers are the support team for students, your editor is on your team.
So what are some things to consider when choosing the right editor for you?
Think of your editor as someone who
- is on your side
- is supporting you
- is helping you succeed
Your editor should be opinionated and direct. Your editor shouldn’t criticize, condescend, or dampen your process.
If you don’t get what you want, get a new editor. The editing process should be positive and motivating for you.
You want your work to shine. Let an editor guide you to a glowing finished product.
